Aaron: I think there are three reasons the GIS is likely incorrect in this case: 1) There is no street sign there, and Narragansett is pretty good about street signs.  2) The road is blocked now by a large iron gate, which makes it serve more as a driveway now than a road, and 3) I don't think fire and rescue would allow two streets to have names that would sound the same in an emergency call, no matter how close they are to one another.

I've run by it at least four times to check and see, but I am pretty certain the GIS is mistaken in this case. - Mark