So I was looking at https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:name and there was this line under the "do not use name=" section. "If a road has buildings along it with 'County Route 5' in their street address, its name is likely 'County Route 5'." To me, that indicates there should be a "North 56th Street" name here, but you're the local here so I won't push too hard for this.