I don't get it. I was just trying to follow the convention here: we don't typically tag roads in Ontario/Toronto with foot=yes tags as it was done in changeset 34227717. It is not safe or expected for pedestrians to walk on roads.

If we want to tag foot=use_sidepath on this road because there is a sidewalk, how is any other road any different? The sidewalk is already mapped separately, so any routing apps can easily direct pedestrians to follow the sidewalk.

All that said, I don't see any reason to tag this particular road as foot=no either, since, again, this isn't different from any other minor road where pedestrians are not supposed to be walking along. There's quite a bit of car traffic down this road, to boot.