Hi, thanks for flagging this with review_requested. I don’t think we should delete the highway=pedestrian segment, because that will break pedestrian routing. Pedestrians can still walk from Leith Walk to Iona Street, so they should be connected.

Bicycle access is indeed awkward because of the kerbs and planters, but as far as I know it’s legal: the sign at the end of Iona Street is no motor vehicles, not no entry. Surely this is on purpose?

That’s why I added the barrier=kerb, kerb=raised node but left GinaroZ’s bicycle=designated on the highway=pedestrian alone. We could weaken “designated” to “yes”. Another thing we can do on the tagging side is adding the planters (barrier=planter).

Which navigation app was suggesting that you cycle there? We could ask them to avoid routing bicycles over a high kerb where possible.