You appear to be personally defining what valid is without caring for or considering the context of reality on the ground. Maps are not reality.  The idea that open data is inherently good and that adding tags to spatial data that the lay person will not see or act on is borderline negligent. "Well intentioned" spatial data transparency is naive when coupled with lack of pragmatism and a real concern for natural resource damage. Leaning on the "blame the user not the tool" is the same old lazy logic that opponents to gun control rely on. 