Hi Dane,
sorry, I missed this changeset and already have commented on https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/156595429.

After looking at this changeset, I fear instead of a simple polygon you need to use a multipolygon relation for the area with two simple polygons, one of each side of Vacation Way, as members with role "outer".
If this is too demanding for you, I can make the appropriate changes the next days.
Cheers skyper