Hi dmich9,

I have noticed you have been importing new tiles from CANVEC. It is nice to see someone picking up CANVEC import again in an attempt to enhance the landscape rendering of Canada and reduce the current patchwork. However, I have noticed, and this was already visible and a problem in old > 10 year ago imported CANVEC data in OpenStreetMap, that many of the new tiles you added seem to get the Multipolygon representation of forest wrong, where the areas that should be forested are blank, and the majority of the tile's area displays green, even though these high latitude tiles only contain a minority of truly forested area due to mostly sparse tree vegetation. This leads to a false and severe over-representation of forest in the tiles that have this wrong. This is currently clearly visible in the patchwork of green and whitish tiles where the "whitish" tiles with minority green patches seem to represent properly defined forest polygons, and the almost entirely green tiles seem to have it wrong. Are you aware of this major issue in your current workflow, and do you plan to fix this is in a second edit round? (it would be preferable to get it wright the first time, so a not to confront data consumers with problematic data).

Regards,

Marco