sentence1 stringclasses 538
values | sentence2 stringlengths 12 241 | labels stringclasses 2
values | metadata stringlengths 187 265 |
|---|---|---|---|
Male infant circumcision is tantamount to child abuse | Parents have the right to use their best judgment, in the light of medical advice, as to what is in the best interest of their child | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 167, "id": "167:1242", "native_cluster": [1242, 21983, 21984], "perspective_id": 1242, "split_group_id": "fef933218efb79881c8a43c3841468bd378036c8dfb870b490b2ac4317d17814", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
punishment should fit the criminal | It will cause less re-offenders. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 944, "id": "944:7584", "native_cluster": [7584, 26958, 26959], "perspective_id": 7584, "split_group_id": "5806807d512a5ff7d208cb4b81905053d04fc3d223da10b09b666c7be337d791", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
punishment should fit the criminal | The onus should not be on punishing the criminal. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 944, "id": "944:7587", "native_cluster": [7587, 26962, 26963], "perspective_id": 7587, "split_group_id": "5806807d512a5ff7d208cb4b81905053d04fc3d223da10b09b666c7be337d791", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
A government has the obligation to lessen the economic gap between its rich and poor citizens | True individual freedom cannot exist without economic security and independence | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 621, "id": "621:5143", "native_cluster": [5143], "perspective_id": 5143, "split_group_id": "65c87b6a812770a4755450d76b03a348d3722b53aee1f4cff3b116949f318c65", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
A government has the obligation to lessen the economic gap between its rich and poor citizens | The wealth gap does not allow for equality between the rich and the poor and so it should be reduced. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 621, "id": "621:26481", "native_cluster": [26481, 26482, 6653, 5142], "perspective_id": 26481, "split_group_id": "65c87b6a812770a4755450d76b03a348d3722b53aee1f4cff3b116949f318c65", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
We Should Question Authorities | Why is the authority figure there? | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 873, "id": "873:7089", "native_cluster": [7089], "perspective_id": 7089, "split_group_id": "ed5335cdcf38661141693fe311d98547358d2d7596e0a7ae5f40e72c39cd6ec4", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
China should be allowed more control over its own seas | Sovereignty of the Seas | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 660, "id": "660:5487", "native_cluster": [5487, 25819], "perspective_id": 5487, "split_group_id": "84ed17d39aa07b81c4f4cf312c6755f8c1f07736768a2a33d4932720c2c2760e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west | Daesh and the Syrian civil war is nurture terrorism for export | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 299, "id": "299:2213", "native_cluster": [2213], "perspective_id": 2213, "split_group_id": "1a053745c11a1ced7b81528ebbfa777fd7c90244f5176f4cfb5277b55ae23de4", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west | There are other larger threats. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 299, "id": "299:2214", "native_cluster": [2214, 23007, 23008, 23009], "perspective_id": 2214, "split_group_id": "1a053745c11a1ced7b81528ebbfa777fd7c90244f5176f4cfb5277b55ae23de4", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west | The west is insulated by distance from Daesh | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 299, "id": "299:2216", "native_cluster": [2216], "perspective_id": 2216, "split_group_id": "1a053745c11a1ced7b81528ebbfa777fd7c90244f5176f4cfb5277b55ae23de4", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Small countries would be able to pursue their independence without having to rely on larger countries. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:26469", "native_cluster": [26469, 25670, 26470, 25671, 5262, 6621], "perspective_id": 26469, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | All the people worldwide have the same rights and are equal to one another. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:6620", "native_cluster": [6620], "perspective_id": 6620, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:6619", "native_cluster": [6619], "perspective_id": 6619, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1573", "native_cluster": [1573, 22362, 22364], "perspective_id": 1573, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1575", "native_cluster": [1575, 22369, 22370, 22372], "perspective_id": 1575, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Public acknowledgement of the right to nuclear deterrence will benefit the public regulation of nuclear weapons generally | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1570", "native_cluster": [1570], "perspective_id": 1570, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Nuclear weapons give states valuable agenda-setting power on the international stage | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1568", "native_cluster": [1568, 22357, 22359], "perspective_id": 1568, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | All countries have a right to defend themselves with nuclear weapons, even when they lack the capacity in conventional weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1566", "native_cluster": [1566, 22353, 22354, 22355, 22356], "perspective_id": 1566, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1574", "native_cluster": [1574], "perspective_id": 1574, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1984", "native_cluster": [1984, 22727, 22728, 5255], "perspective_id": 1984, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 3]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | [Iran specific] Iran has threatened to destroy Israel | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1986", "native_cluster": [1986, 22729], "perspective_id": 1986, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 3]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | No country has an inherent right to invade or use aggression against another. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1989", "native_cluster": [1989], "perspective_id": 1989, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | The United States has an obligation to protect international stability due to its unique military strength. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1982", "native_cluster": [1982, 22725, 22726], "perspective_id": 1982, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | [Iran specific] Others, particularly Israel, would act if the United States did not | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:1987", "native_cluster": [1987, 22731], "perspective_id": 1987, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:5265", "native_cluster": [5265], "perspective_id": 5265, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Disarmament is impossible, rendering efforts to disarm pointless and simply wasteful | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:5264", "native_cluster": [5264], "perspective_id": 5264, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 1, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:5263", "native_cluster": [5263], "perspective_id": 5263, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:5257", "native_cluster": [5257], "perspective_id": 5257, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | States will give terrorists nuclear weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:5254", "native_cluster": [5254], "perspective_id": 5254, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:5256", "native_cluster": [5256], "perspective_id": 5256, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence | It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 825, "id": "825:5258", "native_cluster": [5258], "perspective_id": 5258, "split_group_id": "b53a730b68c2b38bc0dbed75eee4a7c3a99812d38196c07295eccdb5eed1404e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | Too many innocents killed | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2727", "native_cluster": [2727, 23344, 23345], "perspective_id": 2727, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | Can be reserved for the worst of the worst | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2724", "native_cluster": [2724, 23342, 23343], "perspective_id": 2724, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | Necessary for punitive justice | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2722", "native_cluster": [2722, 23018, 2220], "perspective_id": 2722, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | Killers must die to satisfy society | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2725", "native_cluster": [2725], "perspective_id": 2725, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | There are more efficient policies than death penalty | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:5608", "native_cluster": [5608, 25893, 25894], "perspective_id": 5608, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | we are increasing the hate inside terrorist organizations and the dead person will be seen as a hero that animates their fight. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:5609", "native_cluster": [5609, 25895, 25896], "perspective_id": 5609, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | Execution helps alleviate the overcrowding of prisons. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2221", "native_cluster": [2221, 23019, 23020], "perspective_id": 2221, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [3, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | The death penalty can produce irreversible miscarriages of justice. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2225", "native_cluster": [2225, 23025, 23026], "perspective_id": 2225, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 4, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | The death penalty is a financial burden on the state. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2223", "native_cluster": [2223, 23023, 23024], "perspective_id": 2223, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | The penalty of death is a crime deterrent. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:23011", "native_cluster": [23011, 23012, 23013, 23014, 2218, 2219], "perspective_id": 23011, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals | State-sanctioned killing is wrong. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 366, "id": "366:2222", "native_cluster": [2222, 23021, 23022], "perspective_id": 2222, "split_group_id": "56d6f328fbe89dbda6f25e0a79c1a7d7f4e4fe0a83d5b4a9570b8bbb172deda3", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
Sunbeds should be banned | Unmanned salons are legal, yet deadly | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 777, "id": "777:6348", "native_cluster": [6348, 26288, 26289, 26290, 26291], "perspective_id": 6348, "split_group_id": "db48e0481ab521aea8f6d6f7465195f56f40d43b2e873ef796adbb80cfbe4b41", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing | Decreased Conflict and the end of the mercenary age | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 334, "id": "334:2481", "native_cluster": [2481, 23188], "perspective_id": 2481, "split_group_id": "d33cfedec2713f03f722dbfe8a8efaa7e2be3a3a15ae6dfd6a9d3637aafeccd9", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing | Mercenaries are still hired by NGOs | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 334, "id": "334:2485", "native_cluster": [2485, 23192, 23193], "perspective_id": 2485, "split_group_id": "d33cfedec2713f03f722dbfe8a8efaa7e2be3a3a15ae6dfd6a9d3637aafeccd9", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing | Mercenaries still have a presence in coups | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 334, "id": "334:2484", "native_cluster": [2484, 23190, 23191], "perspective_id": 2484, "split_group_id": "d33cfedec2713f03f722dbfe8a8efaa7e2be3a3a15ae6dfd6a9d3637aafeccd9", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing | Legislation against mercenaries | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 334, "id": "334:2480", "native_cluster": [2480, 23186], "perspective_id": 2480, "split_group_id": "d33cfedec2713f03f722dbfe8a8efaa7e2be3a3a15ae6dfd6a9d3637aafeccd9", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
We must use Unmanned Aerial Vehicles to strike terrorist targets | Using drones blurs the distinction between war and peace. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 222, "id": "222:1653", "native_cluster": [1653], "perspective_id": 1653, "split_group_id": "7c517771a79afdc5200195ea4e75a733dd3c307bb2792ca7ba79b383ef06fdbf", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law | Internet anonymity allows people to speak the truth without fearing harm to their careers | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 163, "id": "163:1207", "native_cluster": [1207, 21953], "perspective_id": 1207, "split_group_id": "93af72e11b81264dd7e994c39e33c6a6019ba46eceb403a82e51a00931b819b6", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law | Internet anonymity enables citizens to exercise their right to free speech | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 163, "id": "163:1206", "native_cluster": [1206, 21951], "perspective_id": 1206, "split_group_id": "93af72e11b81264dd7e994c39e33c6a6019ba46eceb403a82e51a00931b819b6", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law | Internet anonymity leads to spam | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 163, "id": "163:1210", "native_cluster": [1210, 21959], "perspective_id": 1210, "split_group_id": "93af72e11b81264dd7e994c39e33c6a6019ba46eceb403a82e51a00931b819b6", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law | Internet anonymity increases cyberbullying and trolling | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 163, "id": "163:1211", "native_cluster": [1211, 21961, 21962], "perspective_id": 1211, "split_group_id": "93af72e11b81264dd7e994c39e33c6a6019ba46eceb403a82e51a00931b819b6", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law | Internet anonymity allows people to experiment and construct with new social identities | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 163, "id": "163:1208", "native_cluster": [1208, 21955, 21956], "perspective_id": 1208, "split_group_id": "93af72e11b81264dd7e994c39e33c6a6019ba46eceb403a82e51a00931b819b6", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law | Internet anonymity allows internet users to engage in illegal activities | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 163, "id": "163:1209", "native_cluster": [1209, 21957, 21958], "perspective_id": 1209, "split_group_id": "93af72e11b81264dd7e994c39e33c6a6019ba46eceb403a82e51a00931b819b6", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council | It would make the UNSC more effective and efficient | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 843, "id": "843:6833", "native_cluster": [6833], "perspective_id": 6833, "split_group_id": "dcaa5ef82a56a4ec2e2bd69e691b15518644cadc9d583bd3fd5d8b0c7a22f232", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council | Argument 2: UNSC sanctions become powerless without PM | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 843, "id": "843:6838", "native_cluster": [6838, 26579, 26580], "perspective_id": 6838, "split_group_id": "dcaa5ef82a56a4ec2e2bd69e691b15518644cadc9d583bd3fd5d8b0c7a22f232", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council | It will lead to fair regional representation, as well as make it more legitimate and flexible | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 843, "id": "843:6835", "native_cluster": [6835, 26577, 26578], "perspective_id": 6835, "split_group_id": "dcaa5ef82a56a4ec2e2bd69e691b15518644cadc9d583bd3fd5d8b0c7a22f232", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council | Argument 1: PM serves interests of developing countries | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 843, "id": "843:6837", "native_cluster": [6837], "perspective_id": 6837, "split_group_id": "dcaa5ef82a56a4ec2e2bd69e691b15518644cadc9d583bd3fd5d8b0c7a22f232", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
A ‘wall’ on the shared USA and Mexico border would be ineffective | At the very least it slows people down | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 470, "id": "470:3499", "native_cluster": [3499], "perspective_id": 3499, "split_group_id": "9bb1a8ccac05878e0957de3e005dd4fb9b608f6585ac1f914dd5dc991aee773c", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Britain should scrap the monarchy | The Monarchy is backward and prejudiced | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 711, "id": "711:5894", "native_cluster": [5894, 26048, 26049], "perspective_id": 5894, "split_group_id": "3bb2f2ba0d80c09fa842add228582e978aac97521aebcae3e602e7d42240ac1b", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should scrap the monarchy | The Monarchy contrasts the meaning of Democracy | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 711, "id": "711:5898", "native_cluster": [5898], "perspective_id": 5898, "split_group_id": "3bb2f2ba0d80c09fa842add228582e978aac97521aebcae3e602e7d42240ac1b", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should scrap the monarchy | It is costing the tax payers money which could be better spent | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 711, "id": "711:5896", "native_cluster": [5896, 26052, 26053, 26054, 26055], "perspective_id": 5896, "split_group_id": "3bb2f2ba0d80c09fa842add228582e978aac97521aebcae3e602e7d42240ac1b", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should scrap the monarchy | Monarchy is a child's creation | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 711, "id": "711:5899", "native_cluster": [5899, 26056, 26057, 26058, 26059], "perspective_id": 5899, "split_group_id": "3bb2f2ba0d80c09fa842add228582e978aac97521aebcae3e602e7d42240ac1b", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should scrap the monarchy | Most other countries in Europe have abandoned the monarch | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 711, "id": "711:6538", "native_cluster": [6538], "perspective_id": 6538, "split_group_id": "3bb2f2ba0d80c09fa842add228582e978aac97521aebcae3e602e7d42240ac1b", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should scrap the monarchy | The head of state should be a position that is separate and distinct from politics | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 711, "id": "711:1902", "native_cluster": [1902, 22646, 22647], "perspective_id": 1902, "split_group_id": "3bb2f2ba0d80c09fa842add228582e978aac97521aebcae3e602e7d42240ac1b", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 2, 0]} |
Britain should scrap the monarchy | There is no divine right to leadership or privilege | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 711, "id": "711:1900", "native_cluster": [1900, 22643], "perspective_id": 1900, "split_group_id": "3bb2f2ba0d80c09fa842add228582e978aac97521aebcae3e602e7d42240ac1b", "votes": [3, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Housewives should be paid for their work | Paying housewives for their work is an important form of economic empowerment. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 103, "id": "103:767", "native_cluster": [767, 21588, 21589], "perspective_id": 767, "split_group_id": "1bbbeff0b348203bf4a4aa603c18f383113e0191a8e1a16edb24935f2dfb9b8e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Housewives should be paid for their work | Payment and obligation works differently in public and in private. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 103, "id": "103:768", "native_cluster": [768, 21590, 21591], "perspective_id": 768, "split_group_id": "1bbbeff0b348203bf4a4aa603c18f383113e0191a8e1a16edb24935f2dfb9b8e", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Housewives should be paid for their work | Paying housewives is financially impractical. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 103, "id": "103:770", "native_cluster": [770, 21594, 21595], "perspective_id": 770, "split_group_id": "1bbbeff0b348203bf4a4aa603c18f383113e0191a8e1a16edb24935f2dfb9b8e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Housewives should be paid for their work | Housewives are entitled to pay | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 103, "id": "103:765", "native_cluster": [765, 21585], "perspective_id": 765, "split_group_id": "1bbbeff0b348203bf4a4aa603c18f383113e0191a8e1a16edb24935f2dfb9b8e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Housewives should be paid for their work | Paying housewives reduces social mobility | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 103, "id": "103:769", "native_cluster": [769, 21592, 21593], "perspective_id": 769, "split_group_id": "1bbbeff0b348203bf4a4aa603c18f383113e0191a8e1a16edb24935f2dfb9b8e", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Housewives should be paid for their work | Paying housewives promotes more positive images of women and family life | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 103, "id": "103:766", "native_cluster": [766, 21586, 21587], "perspective_id": 766, "split_group_id": "1bbbeff0b348203bf4a4aa603c18f383113e0191a8e1a16edb24935f2dfb9b8e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons. | Fair use can be misused | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 973, "id": "973:7798", "native_cluster": [7798, 27072, 27073], "perspective_id": 7798, "split_group_id": "154113d50a4b29173fb710f38bde1cc9f54c3a74be2cf50f52e45954e6b6b3cf", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons. | Establishes a Clear Brightline in Favor of Data Freedom | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 973, "id": "973:7795", "native_cluster": [7795, 27070, 27071], "perspective_id": 7795, "split_group_id": "154113d50a4b29173fb710f38bde1cc9f54c3a74be2cf50f52e45954e6b6b3cf", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Remove Bush tax cuts for the wealthy | Expiring Tax Cuts Would Cause a Double Dip Recession | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 314, "id": "314:2326", "native_cluster": [2326, 23079, 23080], "perspective_id": 2326, "split_group_id": "bab26a7af3ee89124dc369e22c05461ead6035888156ea8c7ca7ec5517b33911", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Remove Bush tax cuts for the wealthy | Removing Tax Cuts Would Reduce the Deficit | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 314, "id": "314:2323", "native_cluster": [2323, 23077], "perspective_id": 2323, "split_group_id": "bab26a7af3ee89124dc369e22c05461ead6035888156ea8c7ca7ec5517b33911", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Neil Armstrong did actually walk on the Moon | the USA had every incentive to lie | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 785, "id": "785:6389", "native_cluster": [6389], "perspective_id": 6389, "split_group_id": "f0e3274b5321524adac96d90f7dd030710b3a477ed3770c671e8e4fd24029396", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Neil Armstrong did actually walk on the Moon | There are problems with the pictures | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 785, "id": "785:6390", "native_cluster": [6390, 26307, 26308], "perspective_id": 6390, "split_group_id": "f0e3274b5321524adac96d90f7dd030710b3a477ed3770c671e8e4fd24029396", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Cannabis should be legalised | Cannabis is a gateway drug | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 35, "id": "35:274", "native_cluster": [274, 21111, 21112], "perspective_id": 274, "split_group_id": "0d6155a2f5ce9aac203c31ad7ba8fa13bcabd9ec39c2629d68cd5408ccc1987f", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Cannabis should be legalised | Uncertainty over the effects of cannabis means it is best to be prudent | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 35, "id": "35:275", "native_cluster": [275, 21113], "perspective_id": 275, "split_group_id": "0d6155a2f5ce9aac203c31ad7ba8fa13bcabd9ec39c2629d68cd5408ccc1987f", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Cannabis should be legalised | People should be allowed to do whatever they want to their own bodies | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 35, "id": "35:270", "native_cluster": [270], "perspective_id": 270, "split_group_id": "0d6155a2f5ce9aac203c31ad7ba8fa13bcabd9ec39c2629d68cd5408ccc1987f", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Cannabis should be legalised | Cannabis is harmful | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 35, "id": "35:277", "native_cluster": [277, 21115, 21116], "perspective_id": 277, "split_group_id": "0d6155a2f5ce9aac203c31ad7ba8fa13bcabd9ec39c2629d68cd5408ccc1987f", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Cannabis should be legalised | Cannabis opens the mind in a positive and beneficial manner | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 35, "id": "35:273", "native_cluster": [273, 21109, 21110], "perspective_id": 273, "split_group_id": "0d6155a2f5ce9aac203c31ad7ba8fa13bcabd9ec39c2629d68cd5408ccc1987f", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Cannabis should be legalised | If cannabis was legalized, it could be regulated | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 35, "id": "35:272", "native_cluster": [272, 21107, 21108], "perspective_id": 272, "split_group_id": "0d6155a2f5ce9aac203c31ad7ba8fa13bcabd9ec39c2629d68cd5408ccc1987f", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Cannabis should be legalised | Alcohol and tobacco are more harmful drugs, yet remain legal. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 35, "id": "35:271", "native_cluster": [271, 21105, 21106], "perspective_id": 271, "split_group_id": "0d6155a2f5ce9aac203c31ad7ba8fa13bcabd9ec39c2629d68cd5408ccc1987f", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return | The Palestinian refugee crisis was created and is perpetuated by the Arab states and the Palestinians themselves | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 91, "id": "91:680", "native_cluster": [680], "perspective_id": 680, "split_group_id": "ab28a393698cbd250fee53006f7f2e451c9bf78d8223f0269e6abe59dd37c952", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return | Palestinians have a right to return under international law | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 91, "id": "91:677", "native_cluster": [677, 21524, 21525], "perspective_id": 677, "split_group_id": "ab28a393698cbd250fee53006f7f2e451c9bf78d8223f0269e6abe59dd37c952", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return | No real 'right of return' exists in international law | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 91, "id": "91:681", "native_cluster": [681, 21528, 21529], "perspective_id": 681, "split_group_id": "ab28a393698cbd250fee53006f7f2e451c9bf78d8223f0269e6abe59dd37c952", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return | A Palestinian right of return would destroy the 'Jewish State' in Israel | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 91, "id": "91:679", "native_cluster": [679, 21526, 21527], "perspective_id": 679, "split_group_id": "ab28a393698cbd250fee53006f7f2e451c9bf78d8223f0269e6abe59dd37c952", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Britain should give up its EU rebate | The rebate should go in exchange for CAP reform | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 435, "id": "435:3242", "native_cluster": [3242, 23691], "perspective_id": 3242, "split_group_id": "229ddf19c94501bd35379d9044024503424934608394454fe1e6dd6e5be4440b", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should give up its EU rebate | The Rebate makes membership acceptable to the British people | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 435, "id": "435:3246", "native_cluster": [3246, 23693], "perspective_id": 3246, "split_group_id": "229ddf19c94501bd35379d9044024503424934608394454fe1e6dd6e5be4440b", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed | The AU can bring peace to the continent | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 406, "id": "406:3026", "native_cluster": [3026, 23531, 23532, 23533], "perspective_id": 3026, "split_group_id": "f58e1599ecf4d3bc8c5aed9c26fa9b4a699f3e4a3dc484ea5329e12709824610", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed | African international organisations do not have a history of effectiveness | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 406, "id": "406:3030", "native_cluster": [3030], "perspective_id": 3030, "split_group_id": "f58e1599ecf4d3bc8c5aed9c26fa9b4a699f3e4a3dc484ea5329e12709824610", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed | Integration will fix the problem of borders | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 406, "id": "406:3028", "native_cluster": [3028, 23534, 23535, 23536, 23537], "perspective_id": 3028, "split_group_id": "f58e1599ecf4d3bc8c5aed9c26fa9b4a699f3e4a3dc484ea5329e12709824610", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed | The role of leaders will prevent success | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 406, "id": "406:3032", "native_cluster": [3032], "perspective_id": 3032, "split_group_id": "f58e1599ecf4d3bc8c5aed9c26fa9b4a699f3e4a3dc484ea5329e12709824610", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Taxes on smoothies and fruit juices should be reduced | Removing VAT would increase sales of healthy drinks | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 886, "id": "886:7146", "native_cluster": [7146], "perspective_id": 7146, "split_group_id": "94f3336b49a327d701a67caa9d57d67ec2245efc44f8af68f3711d49f33bf920", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The International Criminal Court is a force for good | The ICC does not have enough checks on prosecutorial powers, inviting prosecutorial abuse. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 30, "id": "30:233", "native_cluster": [233, 21071, 21072], "perspective_id": 233, "split_group_id": "5ff9443c63135f84e2ecb8184b76ea4ccb13c0a085fcced0115a29446b538dde", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The International Criminal Court is a force for good | The ICC is not democratic in nature and is likely to be used as a political tool by powerful nations. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 30, "id": "30:235", "native_cluster": [235, 21073, 21074], "perspective_id": 235, "split_group_id": "5ff9443c63135f84e2ecb8184b76ea4ccb13c0a085fcced0115a29446b538dde", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The International Criminal Court is a force for good | The ICC interferes with national operations (both military and humanitarian) because of how loosely the Rome Statue can be interpreted. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 30, "id": "30:232", "native_cluster": [232, 21069, 21070], "perspective_id": 232, "split_group_id": "5ff9443c63135f84e2ecb8184b76ea4ccb13c0a085fcced0115a29446b538dde", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The International Criminal Court is a force for good | The ICC infringes upon national sovereignty by inherently implying that there is a higher court nations must answer to. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 30, "id": "30:236", "native_cluster": [236, 21075, 21076], "perspective_id": 236, "split_group_id": "5ff9443c63135f84e2ecb8184b76ea4ccb13c0a085fcced0115a29446b538dde", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
perspectrum
PERSPECTRUM native claim/perspective stance with original claim partitions.
Joins the official perspective pool; uses the first original perspective in each annotated cluster, without expanding paraphrases or inventing negatives. Original distribution: https://github.com/CogComp/perspectrum/tree/master/data/dataset. Dataset terms: CC BY-SA 4.0, recorded in the original data/dataset/license.txt.
Original data: original distribution. Repackaged as parquet for tasksource by scripts/repackage_dataset/stance.py.
Conversion provenance: source revisions, hashes, configuration and exclusions.
- Downloads last month
- -