Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
Target_Summary_ID
stringclasses
200 values
Target_Sentence_Index
stringlengths
4
7
External
stringclasses
2 values
Target_Sentence_factual
stringlengths
19
592
Target_Sentence_non_factual
stringlengths
19
592
Original_Abstract
stringclasses
200 values
t0
t0_1
yes
The skin patch and the vaginal (birth canal) ring are two methods of birth control.
The skin patch and the vaginal (birth canal) ring are five methods of birth control.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_2
yes
Both methods contain the hormones estrogen and progestin.
Both methods contain the hormones testosterone and progestin.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_3
yes
The patch is a small, thin, adhesive square that is applied to the skin.
The patch is a large, thin, adhesive square that is applied to the skin.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_4
yes
The contraceptive vaginal ring is a flexible, lightweight device that is inserted into the vagina.
The contraceptive vaginal ring is a rigid, lightweight device that is inserted into the vagina.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_5
yes
Both methods release drugs like those in birth control pills.
Both methods release chemicals like those in birth control pills.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_6
yes
These methods could be used more consistently than pills because they do not require a daily dose.
These methods could not be used more consistently than pills because they do not require a daily dose.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_7
yes
This review looked at how well the methods worked to prevent pregnancy, if they caused bleeding problems, if women used them as prescribed, and how safe they were.
This review looked at how well the methods worked to prevent pregnancy, if they caused bleeding problems, if women avoided them as prescribed, and how safe they were.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_8
no
Through February 2013, we did computer searches for randomized controlled trials of the skin patch or vaginal ring compared to pills for birth control.
Through February 2013, we did computer searches for randomized controlled trials of the skin patch or vaginal ring compared to injections for birth control.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_9
yes
Pills included types with both estrogen and progestin.
Pills included types with both testosterone and progestin.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_10
no
We wrote to researchers to find other trials.
We wrote to researchers to ignore other trials.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_11
no
We found 18 trials.
We found 25 trials.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_12
no
Of six patch trials, five compared the marketed patch to birth control pills and one studied a patch being developed.
Of eight patch trials, five compared the marketed patch to birth control pills and one studied a patch being developed.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_13
no
Of 12 ring trials, 11 looked at the marketed ring and pills while one studied a ring being developed.
Of 15 ring trials, 11 looked at the marketed ring and pills while one studied a ring being developed.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_14
yes
The methods compared had similar pregnancy rates.
The methods compared had dissimilar pregnancy rates.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_15
no
Patch users reported using their method more consistently than the pill group did.
Patch users reported using their method less consistently than the pill group did.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_16
yes
Only half of the patch studies had data on pregnancy or whether the women used the method correctly.
Only two-thirds of the patch studies had data on pregnancy or whether the women used the method correctly.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_17
yes
However, most of the ring studies had those data.
However, most of the ring studies did not have those data.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_18
no
Patch users were more likely than pill users to drop out early from the trial.
Patch users were less likely than pill users to drop out early from the trial.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_19
no
Ring users were not more likely to drop out early.
Ring users were more likely to drop out early.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_20
no
Compared to pill users, users of the marketed patch had more breast discomfort, painful periods, nausea, and vomiting.
Compared to pill users, users of the marketed patch had less breast discomfort, painful periods, nausea, and vomiting.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_21
no
Ring users had more vaginal irritation and discharge than pill users but less nausea, acne, irritability, depression, and emotional changes.
Ring users had more vaginal irritation and discharge than pill users but more nausea, acne, irritability, depression, and emotional changes.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_22
yes
Ring users often had fewer bleeding problems than pill users.
Ring users often had more bleeding problems than pill users.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_23
yes
The quality of information was classed as low for the patch trials and moderate for the ring studies.
The quality of information was classed as high for the patch trials and moderate for the ring studies.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_24
yes
Lower quality was due to not reporting how groups were assigned or not having good outcome measures.
Higher quality was due to not reporting how groups were assigned or not having good outcome measures.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_25
no
Other issues were high losses and taking assigned women out of the analysis.
Other issues were low losses and taking assigned women out of the analysis.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t0
t0_26
yes
Studies of the patch and ring should provide more detail on whether women used the method correctly.
Studies of the patch and ring should provide less detail on whether women used the method correctly.
The delivery of combination contraceptive steroids from a transdermal contraceptive patch or a contraceptive vaginal ring offers potential advantages over the traditional oral route. The transdermal patch and vaginal ring could require a lower dose due to increased bioavailability and improved user compliance. Objectiv...
t1
t1_1
no
Excess body weight has become a health problem around the world.
Excess body weight has not become a health problem around the world.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_2
no
Being overweight or obese may affect how well some birth control methods work to prevent pregnancy.
Being overweight or obese may not affect how well some birth control methods work to prevent pregnancy.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_3
no
Hormonal birth control includes pills, the skin patch, the vaginal ring, implants, injectables, and hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC).
Hormonal birth control includes pills, the skin patch, the vaginal ring, implants, injectables, and hormonal intrauterine contraception (CIV).
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_4
no
Until 4 August 2016, we did computer searches for studies of hormonal birth control among women who were overweight or obese.
Until 6 August 2016, we did computer searches for studies of hormonal birth control among women who were overweight or obese.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_5
yes
We looked for studies that compared overweight or obese women with women of normal weight or body mass index (BMI).
We looked for studies that compared overweight or obese women with women of abnormal weight or body mass index (BMI).
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_6
yes
The formula for BMI is weight (kg) / height (m) 2 .
The formula for BMI is weight (kg) / height (m) 3 .
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_7
no
We included all study designs.
We excluded all study designs.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_8
no
For the original review, we wrote to investigators to find other studies we might have missed.
For the original review, we wrote to investigators to lose other studies we might have missed.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_9
no
With 8 studies added in this update, we had 17 with a total of 63,813 women.
With 10 studies added in this update, we had 17 with a total of 63,813 women.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_10
no
We focus here on 12 studies with high, moderate, or low quality results.
We focus here on 15 studies with high, moderate, or low quality results.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_11
no
Most did not show more pregnancies for overweight or obese women.
Most did not show fewer pregnancies for overweight or obese women.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_12
no
Two of five studies using birth control pills found differences between BMI groups.
Three of five studies using birth control pills found differences between BMI groups.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_13
no
In one, overweight women had a higher pregnancy risk.
In one, overweight women had a lower pregnancy risk.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_14
no
The other found a lower pregnancy rate for obese women versus nonobese women.
The other found a higher pregnancy rate for obese women versus nonobese women.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
t1
t1_15
yes
The second study also tested a new skin patch.
The third study also tested a new skin patch.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions around the world. Effectiveness of hormonal contraceptives may be related to metabolic changes in obesity or to greater body mass or body fat. Hormonal contraceptives include oral contraceptives (OCs), injectables, implants, hormonal intrauterine contraception (IUC), the transde...
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

PlainFact is a high-quality human-annotated dataset with fine-grained explanation (i.e., added information) annotations designed for Plain Language Summarization tasks, along with PlainQAFact factuality evaluation framework. It is collected from the Cochrane database sampled from CELLS dataset (Guo et al., 2024). PlainFact is a sentence-level benchmark that splits the summaries into sentences with fine-grained explanation annotations. In total, we have 200 plain language summary-abstract pairs (2,740 sentences). In addition to all factual plain language sentences, we also generate contrasting non-factual examples for each plain language sentence. These contrasting examples are perturbed using GPT-4o, following the perturbation criteria for faithfulness introduced in APPLS (Guo et al., 2024).

Currently, we only released the annotation for Explanation sentences. We will release the full version of PlainFact soon (including Category and Relation information). Stay tuned!

Here are explanations for the headings:

  • Target_Sentence_factual: The all factual plain language sentence.
  • Target_Sentence_non_factual: The perturbed (non-factual) plain language sentence.
  • External: Whether the sentence includes information does not explicitly present in the scientific abstract. (yes: explanation, no: simplification). For our fine-tuned plain language summary classifier, visit: uzw/plainqafact-pls-classifier
  • Original_Abstract: The scientific abstract corresponding to each sentence/summary.

You can load our dataset as follows:

from datasets import load_dataset
plainfact = load_dataset("uzw/PlainFact")

For detailed information regarding the dataset or factuality evaluation framework, please refer to our Github repo and paper at https://huggingface.co/papers/2503.08890.

Citation If you use data from PlainFact or PlainFact-summary, please cite with the following BibTex entry:

@misc{you2025plainqafactautomaticfactualityevaluation,
      title={PlainQAFact: Retrieval-augmented Factual Consistency Evaluation Metric for Biomedical Plain Language Summarization}, 
      author={Zhiwen You and Yue Guo},
      year={2025},
      eprint={2503.08890},
      archivePrefix={arXiv},
      primaryClass={cs.CL},
      url={https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.08890}, 
}
Downloads last month
130

Models trained or fine-tuned on uzw/PlainFact

Paper for uzw/PlainFact